YovluA challenge

Can three little notes sound like a question?

Up, down, or same. Hold one longer and see what you hear.

Music · 5 min

Started by Leo Bennett

Cover for Can three little notes sound like a question?

The invitation

Imagine three notes. Write their directions as up, down, or same, and give them a mood. Try holding one longer; you don't need notation, an instrument, or a recording.

First step

Imagine three notes and describe their shape using up, down, or same.

  1. Imagine three notes and describe their shape using up, down, or same.
  2. Try making one of the three notes longer and see whether the mood changes.
  3. Write the three directions and a mood, with a note about any held or repeated sound.

Shared versions

Sofia Duarte

Inspired by Leo Bennett

Shared version of Can three little notes sound like a question?

up / same / down. I held the second high note longer than yours. The drop feels like giving up waiting for an answer.

Leo Bennett

Shared version of Can three little notes sound like a question?

same / up / down. Three slow notes in my head. The middle asks a question; the last is a small 'okay'.

Leo Bennett

Inspired by Alex Morgan

Shared version of Can three little notes sound like a question?

same / same / up, with a gap before that last note. Keeping your nearly-ready feeling, but it takes longer to get there. I'd probably turn the gap into a loop.

Alex Morgan

Shared version of Can three little notes sound like a question?

same / same / up. Three equally spaced notes, the last a little brighter. I'd call it 'nearly ready' rather than cheerful.

Sami Noor

Inspired by Leo Bennett

Shared version of Can three little notes sound like a question?

same / up / down. Your directions, but make the middle note very brief. Less question, more quick interruption.

Nia Brooks

Inspired by Leo Bennett

Shared version of Can three little notes sound like a question?

same / up / same. I'd hold the final high note rather than let it drop. Still waiting for the answer, perhaps.

Jonah Reed

Shared version of Can three little notes sound like a question?

down / down / same. Short, short, held. I imagine a slow landing, though writing 'down' twice doesn't tell you how far it falls.

Conversation

Leo Bennett

I'd repeat the last note once, more softly. More like saying it again to myself.

Hana Kim

That little 'okay' makes sense to me. Would you repeat the last note?

Nia Brooks

Doubt fits too. I don't think the direction alone settles the mood; the length does a lot.

Leila Rahman

I'd hear the held high note as doubt, not waiting. That could be the beginning of a scene.

Sign in to share your version.